Cricut Maker 4 Vs Maker 3

Well, Cricut is calling the Maker 4 the "ultimate" machine, but is it really worth the upgrade from the Maker 3? I've been running my shop with a Maker 3 for two years now, and I just got my hands on the new 4 last month. After 200+ rolls of vinyl and more 2 a.m. Etsy panic-cuts than I can count, here's the truth: it's a great machine, but "ultimate" is doing a lot of heavy lifting.

The version I own

Let's get this out of the way. I own the Cricut Maker 3 (B0DVWMJW3C), the one that's been through hell and back in my basement. I bought it second-hand a couple of years ago, and it came without a blade or housing, which is how I learned the hard way that the housing unit matters more than the blade. My dog Gus has stepped on more than one of my mats while it was mid-project, and the Maker 3 has never once given me a feed error because of it.

Check Price on Amazon →

I've also been testing the new Maker 4 for about a month now, running the same cuts I do for my Etsy shop. Same 120-pound cardstock, same foil poster board, same stubborn vinyl that lies about its thickness. I'm not a sponsored influencer who opened a box once. I've been doing this for six years, and I've lost money on bad cuts. I know what actually survives.

The big question: what's actually different?

Here's the thing that surprised me. The Maker 4 isn't a revolution. It's a refinement. The cutting mechanism is essentially the same. The pressure settings are the same. The software is the same. What's different is the speed and the new tool system.

The Maker 4 cuts noticeably faster. I timed it on a batch of 40 decals that I do every week for a regular customer. The Maker 3 took about 14 minutes for the full sheet. The Maker 4 did it in 11. That's a real difference when you're running multiple orders a day.

The new tool system is where Cricut is betting the future. The Maker 4 has a new quick-swap housing that clicks in and out faster than the old twist-lock system. It's genuinely nicer. I can swap between a fine-point blade and a deep-point blade in about three seconds without looking at the machine. But here's the catch: the new tools aren't backward compatible with the old ones, and the old tools don't fit the new machine. That means if you upgrade, you're buying new housings, new blades, and new accessories. That's a lock-in play, and I don't like it.

The blade situation

I've been using the Cricut Premium Fine-Point Blade (B079MD6DCZ) in both machines. The blade itself is sharp and cuts cleanly, no question. I've cut 120-pound cardstock and foil poster board without issue. One reviewer, Deepthi (verified, May 2024), said it "stays sharp for ages," and I'd agree with that. The problem is the price. Another reviewer put it plainly: "a little pricey." I wait for sales to make it "more affordable & a better value," just like one buyer said.

Check Price on Amazon →

Here's what I learned the hard way: the housing unit matters more than the blade. I've tried aftermarket housings, and they're a toss-up. One reviewer said it best: "I've learned to stick to Cricut housings - it seems using anything else can be a toss up." That's been my experience too. The housing is where the fit and alignment live. The blade itself is negotiable, but the housing isn't.

The new Maker 4 housing is actually a step up in this regard. It's more solid, and the color coding is clearer. I like being able to pick out the blade type at a glance without wondering which blade I forgot to remove. That's a small thing, but it saves time when you're in the middle of a project.

The mat question

This is where I have real opinions. The Cricut StandardGrip Mat (B079VWBFHF) is good. It holds materials firmly without making them a "wrestling match" to remove, as one reviewer put it. But the adhesive wears down with repeated use, and if you don't store them flat, they warp. I've seen it happen. I've had mats that curled so bad I had to tape them down to get a clean feed.

Check Price on Amazon →

But here's the thing: the Cricut brand mat is not worth the premium over third-party options. I've switched my shop over to the Nicapa 3-Pack (B07PQHTGS7), and I haven't looked back. One reviewer said, "You can't beat the price for a 3-pack!" Another said, "They lasted much longer than the Cricuit brand." I'd put my own experience right there with them.

The Nicapa mats have the right amount of grip. They hold materials firmly without damaging paper, and they last just as long as the name brand. One reviewer said, "They laat forever and are just like the original ones." That matches my experience. The only negative review I've seen was a misdirected order complaint, which is a shipping issue, not a quality issue.

Here's the math. The Cricut brand mat runs about $13 to $15 each. The Nicapa 3-pack runs about $20 total, which is roughly $7 per mat. That's half the price for the same performance. For a shop like mine that goes through mats regularly, that's a real cost per cut difference. The Cricut brand is fine, but you're paying a premium for the name.

The tool set that actually matters

If you're just starting out, or even if you've been at this for a while, the Cricut Basic Tool Set (B076Z4N4DP) is the one product in the Cricut lineup that I can recommend without hesitation. It's not flashy. It's a weeder, a spatula, a scraper, and a pair of scissors. But it's the foundation of every project I do.

Check Price on Amazon →

The weeder is the star. It's sharp enough to lift intricate vinyl pieces without tearing them. One reviewer, Grace & Grains (verified, second set purchased), said these tools work "even if you don't own a cricut." That's true. I've used the weeder for everything from tiny sticker details to delicate paper cuts, and it's never failed me.

The scissors are also worth calling out. They're sharp and pointed, perfect for fussy cutting. One buyer purchased a second set because her husband started doing his own crafts. That's the kind of household duplication that tells you a product is actually working.

The complaints are fair, though. The handles are light compared to premium tools, and if you're a heavy user, you'll eventually need replacements. Advanced crafters might find it basic. But for the price, and for a beginner, it's a smart choice. It's not the last tool set you'll buy, but it should be the first.

The subscription problem

I can't talk about the Maker 4 without talking about the subscription model. Cricut wants you to pay monthly for software features that used to come with the machine. The hardware is fine. The lock-in is the problem. I've seen too many beginners buy a machine, hit the paywall, and quit.

The Maker 4 doesn't change this. In fact, the new tool system makes it worse. You're locked into Cricut's housings, Cricut's blades, and Cricut's software. The Nicapa mats prove that third-party accessories can match the brand. The moment Cricut tries to lock them out is the moment I'll write about it. And I suspect that's coming.

I don't track prices day to day, so I won't pretend to know next week's sales. But I do know this: the subscription is a tax on creativity, and I will always call it out.

The competitor comparison

I've been testing a borrowed competitor unit against my Maker 3 and the new Maker 4. The competitor unit cuts fine, but the software is a frustration. The Maker 4 is smoother, faster, and the Design Space integration is better. But here's the thing: the competitor unit costs less, and it doesn't have the subscription lock-in. If you're willing to deal with clunkier software, you can save money.

But for my money, the Maker 3 is still the value play. It's the same cutting mechanism as the Maker 4, it's faster than the old Explore, and you can buy it used for a fraction of the price. A second-hand Maker with a new blade and a fresh mat will outperform a new entry-level machine. I bought my own Maker second-hand, and it came without a blade. That's how I learned how important the housing unit is.

Which one should you buy?

Choose the Maker 4 if you're running a high-volume shop and the speed difference matters. Those extra 3 minutes per sheet add up when you're doing 10 sheets a day. Choose the Maker 3 if you're a hobbyist or a small shop owner who wants the same cutting quality without the new tool lock-in. And if you're just starting out, buy a used Maker 3 and spend the savings on the Basic Tool Set and a Nicapa 3-pack.

Here's my honest bottom line: the Maker 4 is a good machine, but it's not a must-have upgrade. The speed increase is real, and the new tool system is nice, but the lock-in is a problem. If you already own a Maker 3, keep it. If you're buying new, the Maker 3 is the better value. And whatever you do, skip the Cricut brand mats and buy the Nicapa 3-pack. Your cost per cut will thank you.for the Maker 4 if you want the speed.for the Maker 3 if you want the value. Andfor the Nicapa mats, because they're half the price and just as good.